Gift shares, not a bike

June 30th, 2012

So the country’s largest bike maker pulled off another month of record sales even while Bajaj Auto and TVS Motors struggle. The reason for the superlative performance ostensibly is the wedding season in North India, a stronghold of the Delhi-based company. But why is the bike doing so well during the wedding season? The answer could lie in the Indian tradition of showering gifts on the newly weds most of which is borne by the family of the bride. And talking of gifts, what better than to give the beloved Jamai a spanking new Splendor? A bike that will help him expand his business, ferry their daughter back and forth from her sasural and occupy the pride of place among other items of dowry. The bike maker that is searching for a Hero in each one of us has but the current month to sell its bikes to prospective buyers following which starts the Chaturmas  period till October considered inauspicious for weddings.

Given the sales pick up in the season, Hero MotoCorp (HMC) could do well to organize mass marriage ceremonies. This will help it increase its social networth and push it higher on the CSR stakes but also act as an excellent branding platform. Outside the mass pandal, rubbing shoulders with engines of the rural economy—bulls, cows, horses and bullock carts—will be parked the entire range in the HMC armoury right from the entry level CD Dawn to the Karizma ZMR.

Prospective targets (fathers-in-law) don’t have to head to the nearest HMC showroom but instead choose the bike of their liking right from the mandap. Having the bikes at the wedding location means that the son-in-law can pick the model and the colour avoiding the confusion over choice. If this advice is followed, HMC can at least in the marriage season outsmart its rivals and report higher volumes.

While consumer goods are a preferred option, there is a better idea. Why can’t well wishers and, especially in-laws, gift shares of the company? While a bike will have a lifespan of a decade (a stretch), shares of the company could last for generations. While one gift expends money, given the cost of petrol, the other keeps growing and over a period of time turns into a more than sizeable corpus. Consider HMC, the new avatar of Hero Honda Motors. While an investment of Rs 20,000 in  bike would become worthless after a few years to be sold per kilo to the village raddiwala, shares of the company purchased let us say 10 years ago in 2002 would have grown 7.5 times or to a hefty Rs 1,50,000. Extend the period by another 10 years and including dividends it would grow to a whopping Rs 47 lakh, about 234 times over that period. That’s a lot of money. This kind of returns not only take care of inflation and expenditure but also retirement needs, especially in rural India.

The only other asset given to newly weds which has held its own in recent years is gold. Over the last ten years, the yellow metal has returned 465 per cent.

Chuck the durables, gift shares or gold. In-laws will have a kind word to say about your foresight for a long, long time. shares, not a bike digg:Gift shares, not a bike newsvine:Gift shares, not a bike reddit:Gift shares, not a bike Y!:Gift shares, not a bike

Can’t afford an entry-level car

June 4th, 2012

In a slowdown as sharp as this, all product segments in the discretionary spend value chain ought to be impacted. However, the latest auto numbers do not reflect this. Even though India’s largest passenger car company reported a steep drop in volumes of its entry-level or mini segment cars (800, Alto, A-Star, Wagon R), consumers can’t have enough of its diesel-driven compact segment cars -– the Swift and Dzire. Volumes for the two higher-priced cars when consumers are going snip, snip at other expenditure was up between 15-64 per cent.

While the higher running costs for the entry level petrol portfolio is part of the reason, affordability especially for the mid-level consumer seems to be the bigger factor. Given fuel price hikes and a jump in interest costs, price conscious consumers continue to downtrend to the Nano and motorcycles, while costly diesel versions are snapped up by people higher up on the affordability ladder. This probably explains why Maruti’s Ertiga and M&M portfolio of utility vehicles delivered another month of strong growth.

With a 45 per cent price gap between petrol and diesel prices, Maruti’s is forced to offer discounts up to 11 per cent on its petrol vehicles but consumers aren’t taking the bait and instead downtrending or postponing their decisions. With over 65 per cent of its portfolio comprising vehicles running on petrol, the market leader has a tough task on its hands.

While Maruti’s passenger cars volumes and M&M’s tractor volume growth does put a question mark on the strength of the rural economy, Hero MotoCorp’s (HMC) numbers suggest otherwise. As if its high base and recent good performance was not enough, the largest player in the two-wheeler business delivered another strong month of volume growth. Given that rural consumers predominantly buy two wheelers on cash, higher interest costs doesn’t impact HMC’s sales. On the other hand, financing issues and the affordability factor have pegged back Maruti and M&Ms rural sales push.’t afford an entry-level car digg:Can’t afford an entry-level car newsvine:Can’t afford an entry-level car reddit:Can’t afford an entry-level car Y!:Can’t afford an entry-level car