Of mid-career crisis and an MBA

E-Mail This Post/Page
September 9th, 2010 Kalpana Pathak

In the past one month, I have received calls from a couple of my friends asking me for any career enhancement programme that I could suggest.

They have been working for over seven years in the corporate sector and wish to take up a short-term course to get ahead in their area of specialisation.

But to my disappointment, I have not been able to help them so far.

Every expert I speak to, directs me to an MBA programme in some specialization or the other.

What I fail to understand is, why should I go only for an MBA—executive or a full-time or otherwise?

I don’t wish to spend a year or two of my career on the campus or pay a whopping Rs 15-20 lakh for a diploma or certificate programme which will get me back to where I come from.

I wonder if there are any specialised programmes for many such executives who can afford to or would like to spend only around 6 months to pursue a course which helps them specialise in their area of work.

Am sure, distance education could be an option and with every other player today entering into the distance education segment, offering some certificate course or the other, there’s certainly no dearth of options.

But most of these courses add little to your practical knowledge and are beneficial only for the company which starts it. As the CEO of a company (which has launched a string of vocational education programmes in the past few months) rightly put it, “Distance education is the next growth area for our company.”

But let’s face it, employers themselves admit they prefer people with a full-time programme than a course in distance education.

So while you may end up paying a good Rs 2 lakh even for a distance learning programme, there’s no surety if the course will add to your skills or knowledge or will be a source of a better job (if you are looking at that).

In fact, a journalist friend who wished to major in economics, recently enrolled with one of India’s top ten universities for a distance learning programme. She however, quit in two months when at every weekend class she would be told there are no faculty members to take classes and she should come next week.

So even if you are lucky to find the course that you are looking for, there’s no guarantee that you would be able to take it.

Another instance. When a friend was looking for a career in certified financial planning, we called one of the very few institutes that hold the programme. Their official advised me against joining his own institute as they did not have faculty members (He was in exit mode to join a mutul fund organisation).

I wondered, had my friend joined the institute without doing proper homework, she would have paid a good Rs 4 lakh for a two year programme (sans teachers). But yeah, she would have got a free laptop!!

And this is not an isolated example. Two months ago I rang up a highly-recognised local institute for a six-month programme in communication, the co-coordinator said they will begin the programme only when they get enough number of inquiries. They wanted to fill 70 seats. A little more homework on the institute revealed, am doing better off.

This took me back to my student days in journalism classes. I was highly irritated to know that we were still being taught the age old methods of making news papers.

This, when the newspaper organizations themselves graduated to QuarkXPress, years ago.

So while we spent a good Rs 1 lakh for the programme, at the end of the day we would sit with newspaper cuttings trying to place them on a piece of chart paper cut in an eight column size and make dummy newspapers. The most surprising part of the entire exercise was that it was common– at an institute in a three tier town like Visakhapatnam and a metro city like, Delhi.

The sad part is, while the course cost at the institute in Delhi has doubled in the past five years, the age old teaching methodology remains in place. I don’t know how it is at Visakhapatnam now.

Meanwhile, I have suggested to my friends to get in touch with their HR departments and seek recommendation for an executive training programme (from any institute) that the company could have tied up with. Am sure, the companies know it better when it comes to training their manpower.

24 Votes | Average: 4.54 out of 524 Votes | Average: 4.54 out of 524 Votes | Average: 4.54 out of 524 Votes | Average: 4.54 out of 524 Votes | Average: 4.54 out of 5 (24 votes, average: 4.54 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...


All the content posted in the 'Business Standard Blogs' section, unless specified otherwise, are made by Business Standard employees. The content posted in 'Business Standard Blogs' does not follow routine internal Business Standard reviews and editorial processes and should be considered only as the views and opinions of the employees and not of Business Standard.
del.icio.us:Of mid-career crisis and an MBA digg:Of mid-career crisis and an MBA newsvine:Of mid-career crisis and an MBA reddit:Of mid-career crisis and an MBA Y!:Of mid-career crisis and an MBA

5 Responses to “Of mid-career crisis and an MBA”

  1. Asif Says:

    Yes, what Kalpana has written makes sense.
    A cost-benefit analysis has to be done prior to enrolment. Besides, I believe that professional certifications (certification = qualification + recognised work experience) can bring returns to one’s career, and cost very little compared to traditional MBA programmes. It’s not necessary to follow the crowd to do an MBA.

    I found the Association of Professionals in Business Management (APBM)quite good. It was established by an American Indian, Devi Vallabhaneni, a Harvard graduate, and its content appeals to me. The CABM and CBM programmes are quite good. An MBA isn’t employed just because of having those letters after his/her name. In fact, post-qualification expectation will be higher, where in an MBA is required to perform as he/she ought to. Just because there are too many MBAs out there, and many of them are underperformers, a certification called CMBA (certified MBA) has surfaced in the market.

  2. vineet Says:

    MBA is not the alternative for moving up in ur ladder but a must to be in the strategic level
    MBA is generalising every thing but specilizing nothing

  3. Vinayak Says:

    I fully agree to what Kalpana has written. I have searching for this for quite some time but could not find the one. It a challenge for people with over 15 years work experience with full time MBA and costing over 10 lakhs

  4. sanjay Says:

    what i like about educational programs in the US and Canada is that you don’t have to register for a degree / diploma / certificate program to learn what you want. you can even take two classes in the area that interests you. whereas in india to learn anything at an accredited university / college or institute (does not include private classes etc) you have to join a full program whether you want or need it or not. what a waste of revenue opportunity by the educational institutes and lack of continuing education options for the experienced workers in the economy! india is stuck in time in this area - like you said, they teach how to create newspaper using clippings instead of QuarkXpress. sanjay

  5. sanjay Says:

    i am glad kalpana i read this. i am considering a course in business finance from a reputed institute through distance learning. i will do more homework and only join if i am satisfied with the answers and reference checks. thanks, sanjay


All the content posted under the 'Comments' category are made by the readers of Business Standard, unless specified otherwise. Business Standard is not responsible for the opinions of the readers and the content posted by the readers are not representative of the views and opinions of Business Standard.

Leave a Reply