Churn, don’t curtail consumption

E-Mail This Post/Page
August 30th, 2012 Joydeep Ghosh

It’s an interesting thought floated by a friend over lunch. As usual, we were discussing how India is floundering on everything, primary due to the so-called policy paralysis.

Everyone agreed that the government needed to do something to change things, and fast. The thrust of the conversation was that while everyone keeps harping about global problems impacting India, there is little we have done to address our own problems. But, then, what can be done? – Most of us were speechless, as except blaming the government, there were no answers.

Then one of us said – the solution lies in churn. What… churn? – An interesting discussion followed thereafter. Here’s what we journalists call the edited excerpts.

The argument is simple. Say, someone is selling a shirt for Rs 100. The profit: Rs 20. If he reduces the price to Rs 85 and sells two, his profit will increase to Rs 30. But two people would have bought those shirts because the pricing was attractive to a wider audience.

Extending the logic to other sectors, say a builder’s margin is 30 per cent on a property priced at Rs 50 lakh. If the same property is sold Rs 40 lakh, he will attract more buyers.

Importantly, those buyers will take a smaller loan to buy the flat leaving more disposable cash of around Rs 8,000 – Rs 10,000 in this case, in their hands. This is likely to lead to consumption of other goods, say even a car. The rest follows…more expenditure means more requirement of goods and services…more production and so on.

In the economic parlance, it is referred to as increasing the velocity of money and transactions, as more people participate in a competitive market leading to the economic well-being of a larger section of society. To quote Aamir Khan from Three Idiots… more people should say ‘Aal Izzz Well’.

But, many companies or builders are unwilling to take a cut on their margins. And the approach of squeezing the maximum out of a few is hampering growth by keeping potential buyers out of the market.  No wonder, most consumers think even discount sales are gimmicks. Imagine buying jeans for Rs 5,000 in a ‘sale’.

Recently, Analjit Singh, non-executive chairman of Vodafone was explaining that the approach that governments abroad have is quite different. Globally, governments ask companies to focus to top line growth, bottom line growth will automatically take place – something, we don’t focus on aggressively.

How to increase the churn? –Finance Minister P Chidambaram seems to have taken the first step by asking banks (reportedly) to put pressure on builders to cut property rates to encourage buyers. This action needs to be extended to many other sectors.

The builder community is in deep trouble because they have been unable to sell flats and repay banks. And they are finding it hard to sell because they are holding on to prices through help from investors and refinancing from private equity players, venture capitals and even same banks (sometimes, at mind boggling rates of 30 per cent a year). So, instead of selling property, they are busy servicing debt.

Till recently, banks used to charge a prepayment penalty to retail borrowers if they shifted to another bank and ‘did not pay from their own funds’ – a practice both RBI and NHB have stopped now. Why can’t the same logic of ‘refinancing through own funds or a penalty’  extended to corporate India? This will put pressure on them to deliver.

Banks hold the key here. Aggression on their part will help the economy. It will even help improve their books. Who will bell the cat?

10 Votes | Average: 3.7 out of 510 Votes | Average: 3.7 out of 510 Votes | Average: 3.7 out of 510 Votes | Average: 3.7 out of 510 Votes | Average: 3.7 out of 5 (10 votes, average: 3.7 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...

Disclaimer

All the content posted in the 'Business Standard Blogs' section, unless specified otherwise, are made by Business Standard employees. The content posted in 'Business Standard Blogs' does not follow routine internal Business Standard reviews and editorial processes and should be considered only as the views and opinions of the employees and not of Business Standard.
del.icio.us:Churn, don’t curtail consumption digg:Churn, don’t curtail consumption newsvine:Churn, don’t curtail consumption reddit:Churn, don’t curtail consumption Y!:Churn, don’t curtail consumption

2 Responses to “Churn, don’t curtail consumption”

  1. Uday Panse Says:

    This is a highly simplistic view. In a given market trader understands importance of quick transactions. When there are less consumers in the market the demand dips. It forces those traders to do distress sale; for whom servicing debt is costly. Such a move prompts decline in prices.This mechanism is in place since the free trade initiated. The best thing as a consumer we should do is to protect our capital and purchasing power and wait till the bargain sale starts! You just can’t go shopping for the betterment of economy. Only govt who can print currency has that power.

  2. commercial mortgage refinancing Says:

    I am now not certain the place you’re getting your information, however good topic. I must spend a while finding out more or understanding more. Thank you for great information I was searching for this info for my mission.

Disclaimer

All the content posted under the 'Comments' category are made by the readers of Business Standard, unless specified otherwise. Business Standard is not responsible for the opinions of the readers and the content posted by the readers are not representative of the views and opinions of Business Standard.

Leave a Reply